Once you reach Skyhold in Dragon Age Inquisition, you will be able to sit in judgement of prisoners captured during combat and decide their fate. You may gain or lose approval from Companions and potentially gain rewards. Using the Throne in the main hall will activate this quest and it can be reactivated whenever you have a new prisoner.
Note: Companions don't show aproval changes if your choices would raise or drop their aproval past the maximum/minimum.
- Requires Nobility Knowledge perk.
- Requires Mage character.
- Requires Arcane Knowledge perk.
- Requires History Knowledge perk.
- Requires Underworld Knowledge Perk.
- RARE. Requires the Inquisitor to be of a particular race or class, or a specific in-game choice must have been taken previously
Judgments
Prisoner | Capture Locale | Details | Approval |
---|---|---|---|
Avaar Tribesman |
The Fallow Mire | Arm and banish him to Tevinter - Gain as an agent. |
Solas: +1, Dorian: +1, Iron Bull: +3, Blackwall: +1, Sera: +2, Cole: +1, Vivienne: +1 |
Assign him to Abernache. - Gain as an agent. (only available if you sided with the Templars & Abernache lives) - Opens Judgment: Abernache over Under war table mission |
Iron Bull: +2, Sera: +2, Varric: +2, Blackwall: +1, Vivienne: -1 | ||
Place him in a gibbet. | Solas: -1, Iron Bull: -1, Cole: -1 | ||
Drive them out of your lands | Solas: -1, Iron Bull: -1, Sera: +1, Cole: -2 | ||
Alexius |
Redcliffe Castle | He'll serve Redcliffe's mages | Solas: +2, Iron Bull: +1, Blackwall: +1, Sera: -1, Cole: +2 |
I want him researching magic. - Opens Judgement: The Magic Used in Redcliffe war table mission. |
Solas: +2, Cassandra: -1, Iron Bull: +1, Sera: -2, Vivienne: +1, Cole: +1 | ||
I'm executing him myself. | Solas: -1, Iron Bull: +2, Sera: +1, Varric: -1, Cole: +1 | ||
Make him harmless. A Tranquil. | Solas: -3, Cassandra: +1, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: -2, Cole: -2 | ||
Imprison him. | Iron Bull: +2, Cole: -2 | ||
Knight-Captain Denam |
Therinfal Redoubt | Let the Templars judge him. | Solas +1, Cassandra +1, Iron Bull +2, Blackwall +1, Sera +1, Varric +1, Cole +2, Vivienne +1 |
Question then jail him. | Solas +1, Iron Bull +1, Varric +1 | ||
Traditionally he's exiled. | Solas +1, Cassandra +2, Iron Bull +2, Blackwall +1, Sera +1, Cole +1 | ||
I'm Conscripting him. - Opens Judgement: Denam's Red Templar Patrols war table mission. |
Solas -2, Cassandra -2, Blackwall +2, Sera -1, Varric -2, Cole -2 | ||
Servis |
The Western Approach | Give him back to Corypheus. | Solas: +1, Dorian: -1, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: -1, Sera: +2, Varric: -1, Cole: -1 |
An informant. On probation. - Recruits him as an agent. - Opens Judgment: Recover Sold Artifacts war table mission |
Solas: +2, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: +1, Sera: -1, Cole: -2, Vivienne: +1 | ||
I want him as a smuggler. - Recruits him as an agent. |
Solas: +2, Dorian: +1, Cassandra: -1, Iron Bull: +1, Sera: -1, Varric: +1, Cole: -1 | ||
Throw him in jail. | Solas: +1, Iron Bull: +1, Cole: -2 | ||
Mayor Dedrick- Grants Ferelden Throne |
Crestwood | I'll give him a clean death. | Solas: -2, Iron Bull: +2, Sera: +2, Cole: +2 |
The best I can do is exile. | Solas: +2, Iron Bull: -1, Sera: -1, Cole: -1 | ||
Ferelden can lock him up. | Iron Bull: +1, Varric: +1, Cole: -1, Vivienne: +1 | ||
Give him to the Grey Wardens. | Solas: -1, Sera: +1, Vivienne: -1 | ||
Erimond |
Adamant | Tranquil | Solas: -2, Dorian: -2, Vivienne: +2, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: -2, Cole: -2, Cassandra: -1 |
Wardens | Solas: -1, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: +2, Sera +1, Cole +1 | ||
Imprison | Solas: -1, Varric: +1, Dorian: +1, Vivienne: +1, Blackwall: +1, Sera: +1, Cole: -2 | ||
Execution | Solas: +2, Iron Bull: +2, Sera: +2, Cole: +2 | ||
Ser Ruth |
Adamant | I won't Judge a Warden | Solas -2, Cassandra -1, Blackwall +1, Sera +2, Cole -1, Vivienne -1 |
Go to the Deep roads - Operation Unlock: The Judgement of Good Ser Ruth |
Solas -1, Cole +1, Sera +2, Varric +1 | ||
Public Humiliation, then | Solas +2. Blackwall -2, Sera -1, Cole -1, Vivienne +2 | ||
Jail her; Throw Away the Key | Solas -1, Iron Bull -1, Sera -1, Cole +1 | ||
Andraste Forgives You - Operation Unlock: The Good Works of Ser Ruth |
Solas -2, Cole +2 | ||
Grand Duchess Florianne (alive) |
Halamshiral | Common Work with Common People. | Solas: -2, Dorian: +1, Iron Bull: +1, Blackwall: +2, Sera: +2, Cole: +2, Vivienne: +1 |
Exile. Out of my Site. | Solas: -1, Iron Bull: -1, Vivienne: -1 | ||
Jester's Outfit. Bad Shoes. | Cassandra -1, Sera: +2, Vivienne: +1 | ||
Grand Duchess Florianne (dead) |
Halamshiral | My decision is to ignore this. | Cassandra: -1, Sera: -1. |
Ha! Community service! - Gain an agent. (Josephine) - Opens "Judgement: Duchess in a Box tour 9:41" war table mission. |
Cassandra: -1, Sera: +2, Cole: -1 | ||
Fine, let's get this over with. | |||
Thom Rainier |
Val Royeaux | You're free, if you atone. | Sera: +2. |
The Wardens will decide. | Sera: +1 | ||
I own you. Your lie continues. | Blackwall: -3, Sera: -2 | ||
Mistress Poulin- Grants Orlais Throne |
Emprise du Lion | You're free to go. | Solas: +1, Iron Bull: -1, Blackwall +1, Sera: -1, Varric: +1, Cole: +2 |
Put her to work. | Solas: +1, Cassandra: +1, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: +1, Sera: +1,Varric: +1, Cole: +2 | ||
I'm taking your money. - Gain 223 Gold |
Solas: -2, Cassandra: -1, Iron Bull: -1, Blackwall: -1, Varric: -2, Cole: -2 | ||
Treason deserves death. | Solas: +1, Cassandra: +1, Iron Bull: +2, Blackwall: -2, Varric: -2, Cole: -2 | ||
Have her rebuild the town. | Blackwall: -1 Iron Bull: -1, Varric: +2, Sera: +2, Vivienne: +1 | ||
Samson |
The Arbor Wilds | Cullen will question you. - Only available if you chose "Maddox respected you" as previous dialogue option. - Only available if you completed Before the Dawn. |
Iron Bull: +2, Vivienne: +1, Solas: +2 |
Let Kirkwall have you. | Sera: +2, Varric: +2 | ||
Dagna will study your powers. | Dorian: -1 | ||
Shove this coward in a hole. | Cole: -2 | ||
Exile him to wilderness. | Solas: -2, Iron Bull: -1, Varric: -1, Cole: -1 | ||
Storvacker |
Frostback Basin (Jaws of Hakkon DLC) | Cut back on her treats? | No changes in approval. |
We'll "bear" her misconduct | No changes in approval. | ||
I'm recruiting her. - Gain an agent. (Cullen) - Opens "Too Grizzly to Bear" war table mission. |
No changes in approval. | ||
This is punishment enough. | No changes in approval. |
- Anonymous
I had to judge her and I had a fourth option. It gave me Solas and Vivienne Approval and no disapproval. It had a book icon but I have all the knowledge perks so it could be the nobility knowledge one or something. saw that it wasn't in here and should/could be added to help others ^^
If you have enough Nobility Knowledge (by finishing the Black Mail Mission at the Winter Palace you'll gain some points on that). There appears an option "Put her guile to work for us". I am unsure of what that might do, like her becoming an Agent or so. Didn't test it, since I wouldn't trust a snake to do agent work for me o_o
1
+10
-1